Withings vs Eufy Smart Scale Comparison (2026): Which Smart Scale Is Better for Weight, Body Fat, Muscle Tracking, Accuracy, App Features, and Overall Value?

Last Updated on: September 4, 2026

Compare Withings vs Eufy smart scales in 2026 for weight, body fat, muscle tracking, accuracy, app features, and value. Find out which smart scale is best for your health goals.

LifeCareBalance.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

If you already own an entry-level Eufy smart scale, there’s a good chance you’ve asked yourself the same question a lot of people search for: is it actually worth paying more for a Withings scale, especially for body-composition tracking?

It’s a fair question, and it doesn’t have a one-word answer. Both brands make capable connected scales that measure weight, body fat, muscle mass, and other metrics using bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) — the same basic technology found in most consumer body-composition scales. Neither one is a medical device, and neither one will give you lab-grade body-fat numbers. What separates them is less about raw “accuracy” and more about consistency, app experience, ecosystem support, and how the data is presented over time.

This guide compares the Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro and the Withings Body Smart directly — the two models we’ve reviewed in depth on LifeCareBalance, and the pair most people are actually weighing against each other when they type “Withings vs Eufy” into Google. (Withings also sells pricier models like Body Comp, BodyFit, and Body Scan 2, and Eufy has other scales in its lineup — we call those out specifically wherever the comparison could get confusing, rather than mixing specs across models.)

By the end, you’ll know which scale wins for weight tracking, body-fat and muscle tracking, app quality, integrations, and overall value — and, most importantly, whether upgrading from Eufy to Withings is worth the money for your situation.

Quick preview: Withings generally wins on app polish and health-ecosystem integration; Eufy generally wins on value and raw metric count for the price. Neither has been shown in independent testing to be dramatically more accurate than the other for body composition.

Withings vs Eufy Smart Scale: Quick Verdict

• Best Overall: Withings Body Smart — more refined app, broader health integrations, better long-term usability
• Best for Value: Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro — more metrics per dollar, no subscription required for core features
• Best for App/Ecosystem: Withings Body Smart — cleaner dashboard, native Apple Health support, Health Connect support
• Best for Budget Buyers: Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro
• Best for Weight Loss (trend tracking): Tie — both track weight trends reliably; Withings’ app makes trends easier to visualize
• Best for Body-Composition Trend Tracking: Tie — both use single-frequency BIA with similar inherent limitations
• Best for Existing Eufy Owners Deciding Whether to Upgrade: Usually stay with Eufy unless you specifically want Withings’ app, integrations, or additional modes (see the upgrade section below)

Withings vs Eufy Comparison Table

Feature	Withings Body Smart	Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro
Weight tracking	Yes, with 8 user profiles	Yes, multiple user profiles via EufyLife app
Body fat %	Yes (BIA estimate)	Yes (BIA estimate)
Muscle mass	Yes	Yes, plus separate skeletal muscle mass reading
BMI	Yes	Yes
Water / hydration	Yes	Yes
Heart rate	Yes	Yes
Other metrics	Visceral fat index, bone mass, fat mass	Bone mass, protein %, BMR, visceral fat, body fat mass, lean body mass, body age, body type, subcutaneous fat (16 metrics total)
Measurement technology	Bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA), single/dual frequency	Bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA)
Accuracy considerations	No independent DEXA-comparison data located for this exact model; treat body-fat numbers as trend data	Independent lab testing found weight error averaging about 0.09 kg against calibrated standards, with body-fat estimates running roughly 5–7% higher than DEXA in higher-BMI users
App	Withings App	EufyLife app
Wi-Fi	Yes	Yes (2.4GHz networks only)
Bluetooth	Yes	Yes
Apple Health	Yes	Yes
Google Fit / Health Connect	Health Connect (Google Fit was retired by Withings in 2024)	Google Fit support has been advertised; verify current manufacturer specification for Health Connect support
Fitbit	Supported via account import or Health Connect on Android	Supported per manufacturer listing
User profiles	8	Multiple, exact number: verify current manufacturer specification
Display	LED screen	LED display
Battery	Manufacturer-listed battery life around 15 months on AAA batteries	AAA batteries; runtime: verify current manufacturer specification
Weight capacity	397 lbs	397 lbs (180 kg); minimum start weight around 6.6 lbs
Subscription required?	No for core metrics; Withings+ subscription (roughly $99.95/year) unlocks Health Improvement Score and Body Score	No subscription required for core features
Data history	Stored in Withings App, viewable as trends/graphs	Stored in EufyLife app, viewable as trends/graphs
Family use	Up to 8 profiles, plus baby and pregnancy modes	Multiple profiles supported
Price/value	Higher price point (commonly listed around $130, frequently discounted)	Lower price point (commonly under $50)
Best for	Users who want a polished app and deeper health-ecosystem integration	Budget-conscious buyers who want a lot of metrics per dollar

Prices change frequently on both Amazon and manufacturer sites, so treat the figures above as general positioning rather than current pricing — always check the listing before you buy.

Withings Body Smart vs Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro: What Is the Difference?

Withings Body Smart

The Body Smart sits at the entry point of Withings’ current scale lineup (above it are the pricier Body Comp, BodyFit, and Body Scan 2, which add more biomarkers and different sensor designs — those are different products with different specs, not interchangeable with the Body Smart).

Who it’s for: People who want a scale that plugs cleanly into Apple Health or a broader health-tracking routine, and who value app polish as much as raw metrics.

Key strengths: A clean, well-organized app; useful household-friendly modes including Athlete, Pregnancy, Baby, and Eyes Closed (which hides your weight number if you’d rather just track trends); heart rate measurement at every weigh-in; visceral fat index alongside standard body-composition metrics.

Main weaknesses: Some of the more motivational features — Health Improvement Score and Body Score — sit behind a Withings+ subscription, so the “complete” experience isn’t fully free. Some long-term owners have also reported mixed experiences with device longevity and warranty support, which is worth factoring into a purchase decision.

Most useful features: The Eyes Closed mode is genuinely useful for people managing a difficult relationship with the number on the scale, and the multi-mode support makes this a scale that can realistically serve an entire household, including a baby or someone who’s pregnant.

App experience: Widely praised for being easy to navigate, with digestible summaries of body stats rather than an overwhelming data dump.

Value proposition: You’re paying a premium mainly for the app experience, integrations, and household-friendly features — not for a body-composition sensor that’s been shown to be dramatically more accurate than cheaper alternatives.

If you want the full breakdown, read our <a href=”https://lifecarebalance.com/withings-body-smart-scale-review-2026/”>detailed Withings Body Smart review</a>.

Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro

The P2 Pro is a mid-range entry in Eufy’s scale lineup — a different product from the newer Eufy P3 or the budget Eufy BodySense, so don’t assume specs are interchangeable between those models.

Who it’s for: Buyers who want a large number of body-composition metrics without paying a premium, and who don’t need deep Apple/Google health-ecosystem polish.

Key strengths: Sixteen tracked metrics for a fraction of the Withings price, including some — like body age, body type, and subcutaneous fat — that Withings doesn’t break out separately. A 3D virtual body model in the app gives a visual sense of progress over time. IPX5 water resistance is a nice practical touch for a bathroom device.

Main weaknesses: Wi-Fi syncing is limited to 2.4GHz networks, which can trip up households running newer mesh routers on 5GHz-only bands. Some reviewers have also noted sensitivity quirks, and the app, while functional, isn’t quite as visually polished as Withings’.

Most useful features: The sheer breadth of metrics for the price is the P2 Pro’s calling card, along with straightforward Bluetooth/Wi-Fi setup that most reviewers describe as quick and painless.

App experience: The EufyLife app is functional and clearly laid out, with independent testing noting a strong app-store rating and reliable syncing, even if it lacks some of the lifestyle polish of Withings’ app.

Value proposition: For someone who mainly wants trend data across a wide range of metrics without paying for a premium ecosystem, the P2 Pro is hard to beat on price.

Read the full breakdown in our <a href=”https://lifecarebalance.com/eufy-smart-scale-p2-pro-review-2026/”>Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro review</a>.

Withings vs Eufy Accuracy: Which Smart Scale Is More Accurate?

This is the question most buyers actually care about, and it’s also the one that’s easiest to overstate. Here’s what matters:

Weight measurement accuracy — the actual number in pounds or kilograms — tends to be reliable on both scales. Independent lab testing of the Eufy P2 Pro found weight readings averaging roughly 0.09 kg away from calibrated reference standards, which is a strong result for a budget device. We didn’t locate comparable independently published lab data for the Withings Body Smart specifically, though the underlying load-cell technology used in modern digital scales is generally accurate for straightforward weight measurement across brands.

Body-fat estimation is a different story, and this is true industry-wide, not just for these two brands. Both scales use bioelectrical impedance analysis, which sends a very low, imperceptible electrical current through your body and estimates fat, muscle, and water based on how that current travels. It’s a proxy measurement, not a direct one, and it’s sensitive to:

• Hydration levels — being dehydrated or well-hydrated can shift readings
• Foot placement — inconsistent contact with the sensor plates skews results
• Time of day — morning versus evening readings can differ
• Food and exercise — a recent meal or workout changes fluid distribution
• Hard-floor placement — scales generally need a firm, flat surface for accurate readings, not carpet
• Consistency of measurement conditions — weighing at the same time, same hydration state, and same scale placement produces more meaningful trend data than any single reading

The independent testing on the Eufy P2 Pro found body-fat estimates running about 5–7% higher than DEXA (a clinical body-composition method) in people with higher BMI, and skeletal muscle estimates with a standard deviation of around 2.3 kg compared to DEXA. That’s a useful, specific data point — and it also illustrates why no consumer BIA scale, Withings included, should be treated as a clinical-grade tool.

The bottom line: trends matter more than any single reading. If a scale consistently shows your body fat trending down over eight weeks of similar-condition weigh-ins, that trend is meaningful even if the absolute percentage isn’t clinically precise.

Are Withings Body-Fat Measurements More Accurate Than Eufy?

Based on the evidence available, there isn’t strong, independent, head-to-head data proving that Withings’ body-fat readings are more accurate than Eufy’s, or vice versa. We are not going to tell you Withings is “clinically accurate,” and we’re not going to tell you Eufy is “inaccurate” — neither claim is well supported.

What we can say, based on how these devices work:

• Algorithm differences likely exist between brands, since each company uses its own proprietary formulas to convert impedance readings into body-fat percentages, but neither company publishes enough detail for outside groups to fully validate those formulas against clinical standards.
• Sensor configuration matters — foot-only BIA scales like both of these models measure impedance through the lower body and extrapolate to estimate whole-body composition, which introduces more room for error than multi-point systems (like Withings’ own higher-end Body Scan 2, which adds a handle with additional electrodes — a genuinely different measurement approach from the Body Smart).
• Consistency and repeatability — how similar your readings are when you weigh yourself repeatedly under the same conditions — matter more for everyday use than one-off “accuracy” against a lab reference.
• Individual variation in hydration, body shape, and other factors affects BIA readings on any brand’s scale.
• The core limitation is the technology, not the brand. Single-frequency, foot-only BIA scales — which describes both the Body Smart and the P2 Pro — share the same fundamental accuracy ceiling. The National Institutes of Health and similar research bodies have published extensively on the general limitations of BIA-based body-composition estimates compared to clinical methods like DEXA.

If body-composition precision is your top priority above everything else, that’s a reason to look at scales (from any brand, including Withings’ own pricier Body Scan 2) that use more advanced multi-frequency or multi-point sensing — not necessarily a reason to assume any single-frequency foot scale, Withings or Eufy, is meaningfully better than the other.

Withings vs Eufy Body Fat and Muscle Tracking

Both scales estimate body fat percentage, muscle mass, water percentage, and BMI. Eufy’s P2 Pro breaks out a few additional data points — skeletal muscle mass, subcutaneous fat, lean body mass, and body age — that Withings folds into fewer summary metrics. Withings adds a visceral fat index, which Eufy also tracks under its “visceral fat” metric.

For weight loss, both apps make it easy to see a weight trend line over time, which is the metric that matters most. Withings’ app tends to present this more visually, with clearer graphing and goal-tracking; Eufy’s data is all there but arranged in a more utilitarian layout.

For muscle gain or body recomposition, Eufy’s more granular muscle-related metrics (skeletal muscle mass specifically) can be interesting to look at, but keep in mind that all of these numbers are BIA estimates, not lab measurements — so use them as directional feedback (is the trend moving the way you want?) rather than a precise gauge of exactly how much muscle you’ve gained.

For general wellness tracking, Withings’ broader mode support (Athlete, Pregnancy, Baby, Eyes Closed) gives it an edge if your household includes people with different tracking needs.

Withings vs Eufy App Comparison

Setup: Both apps walk you through pairing via Bluetooth first, then optionally connecting to Wi-Fi for background syncing. Eufy’s Wi-Fi setup is limited to 2.4GHz networks, which can be an extra step on newer routers.

Dashboard and historical graphs: Withings’ app is consistently described as clean and easy to navigate, with digestible summaries rather than raw data dumps. Eufy’s EufyLife app is functional and clearly organized, with a distinctive 3D avatar feature that visually represents body-composition changes over time — a feature Withings’ entry-level app doesn’t include.

Goal tracking: Withings ties weight and body-composition goals into a broader Health Improvement Score and Body Score, though full access to those features requires a Withings+ subscription. Eufy’s core goal-tracking (weight target, trend graphs) is included without a subscription requirement.

Data syncing: Both sync automatically over Wi-Fi when configured, and both fall back to Bluetooth. Independent testing noted a sync failure rate under 1% for the EufyLife app during a multi-week evaluation period; we don’t have comparable independently published sync-reliability data for the Withings app, though user reports describe reliable syncing with occasional server-side hiccups.

Health integrations: This is where Withings currently has an edge (see the next section).

Multi-user support: Withings supports up to 8 user profiles with automatic recognition based on weight patterns. Eufy also supports multiple user profiles through the app.

Subscription/premium features: Withings gates some scoring features behind Withings+. Eufy’s core feature set is fully accessible without a subscription.

Overall usability: If you want the more refined, “designed” app experience, Withings generally wins. If you want maximum data without a subscription nudge, Eufy’s app gets the job done.

Withings vs Eufy Connectivity and Health Integrations

Integration	Withings Body Smart	Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro
Apple Health	Supported	Supported
Google Fit	Discontinued by Withings as of May 2024 in favor of Health Connect	Advertised by Eufy on some listings; verify current manufacturer specification, as Google has been phasing out the Google Fit API in favor of Health Connect industry-wide
Google Health Connect	Supported	Verify current manufacturer specification
Fitbit	Supported via Withings’ Fitbit-import tool, or via Health Connect on Android	Supported per manufacturer listing

Google has been retiring the original Google Fit API across the industry in favor of Health Connect, so any smart scale — Withings, Eufy, or otherwise — that still advertises “Google Fit support” should be understood in that context. If Google Fit or Health Connect compatibility is a dealbreaker for you, check each brand’s current app-store listing and support pages before buying, since integration support can change with app updates.

For Apple Health users, both scales work, so this isn’t a strong differentiator on its own — the deciding factor is more likely to be app polish and household features.

For Fitbit or Google-ecosystem users, both brands technically support getting scale data into those platforms, though the process can require a few extra steps (like linking through Health Connect on Android). Neither company advertises a perfectly seamless, one-tap Fitbit integration at this point.

Withings vs Eufy Privacy and Data Considerations

A smart scale stores sensitive personal health data — your weight, body-fat percentage, body-composition trends, and in some cases heart rate — tied to an account. That’s worth taking seriously regardless of which brand you choose.

Neither Withings nor Eufy has been the subject of a well-documented data-privacy scandal specific to their smart scale products, but that doesn’t mean you should skip due diligence. Before buying either scale, review the current privacy policy for the app you’ll be using (Withings App or EufyLife), pay attention to what data is shared with third-party integrations you enable (Apple Health, Fitbit, Health Connect), and check what account permissions the app requests during setup, such as location access.

Withings has publicly stated that some of its newer, more advanced devices are designed to comply with health-data regulations like GDPR and HIPAA, though the specifics can vary by product and region — verify current privacy documentation for the exact model and region you’re buying in rather than assuming blanket coverage. Eufy, a brand under Anker, states in its own product materials that user data is treated confidentially, but as with any connected device, you should read the current policy rather than rely on marketing language.

If data privacy is a top priority, it’s reasonable to favor whichever brand’s current, published privacy policy you’re more comfortable with — that’s a decision only you can make after reading the actual documentation, since policies can be updated at any time.

Withings vs Eufy for Weight Loss

For pure weight-loss tracking, both scales do the core job well: they capture a weight number consistently and let you view it as a trend over days, weeks, and months. What differs is the experience around that trend.

Withings’ app makes it easier to visually track progress and set goals, and the Eyes Closed mode is a genuinely useful option if you want to focus on trends without seeing the day-to-day number, which can be a helpful feature for people prone to over-fixating on small fluctuations. Eufy’s app gives you the same underlying weight-trend data with a more basic (but still functional) presentation.

Recommendation: If app experience and goal visualization matter to your motivation, Withings has an edge. If you just want reliable trend tracking without paying extra for polish, Eufy covers the fundamentals.

Withings vs Eufy for Muscle Gain and Body Recomposition

For strength training and body recomposition, Eufy’s more granular metrics (skeletal muscle mass, lean body mass, body type) give you slightly more to look at session over session. Withings tracks muscle mass as well, folded into its broader body-composition summary, plus the Athlete mode, which is designed with more active users in mind.

It’s worth repeating: neither scale should be treated as a precise instrument for measuring exact muscle gained or fat lost over a training block. Use either scale’s readings as one input alongside how your clothes fit, strength progression, and (if available to you) periodic professional body-composition testing.

Which Is Better for Families?

Both scales support multiple user profiles, which is the baseline requirement for family use. Withings edges ahead here with its 8-profile support and purpose-built modes for pregnancy and babies, which make it easier for a household with young kids or an expecting parent to use one device for everyone. Eufy also supports multiple profiles, though it doesn’t advertise the same dedicated baby/pregnancy modes.

On the privacy side, families sharing one scale should be mindful that body-composition and weight data for multiple household members, including minors, will be stored in the connected app — another reason to review each brand’s current privacy policy before setup, and to set up separate profiles rather than sharing one login across family members.

Is Withings Worth Upgrading to From Eufy?

This is the question at the center of most Withings-vs-Eufy searches, and it deserves a direct answer: it depends on what you’re actually unhappy with in your current Eufy scale.

If your frustration is “I wish my body-fat numbers were more accurate,” upgrading to Withings is unlikely to solve that on its own. Both scales use the same core BIA technology, and there’s no strong independent evidence that Withings’ single-frequency Body Smart produces meaningfully more accurate body-composition estimates than Eufy’s P2 Pro. If clinical-grade accuracy is genuinely the goal, the more honest answer is that no scale in this price range — from either brand — will get you there; that requires a method like DEXA scanning.

If your frustration is with the app experience, ecosystem integration, or household features, upgrading to Withings is much more likely to solve your actual problem.

Upgrade to Withings if:

• You need features your current Eufy model lacks, such as Eyes Closed mode, Pregnancy mode, or Baby mode
• You prefer the Withings app’s cleaner dashboard and goal-tracking layout
• You specifically value Apple Health integration or a more mature health-data workflow
• You’re willing to pay more (and potentially subscribe to Withings+) for a more polished, motivational scoring system
• You want a different overall tracking experience, not just “more accurate” numbers

Stay With Eufy if:

• Your current scale already tracks the metrics you actually check regularly
• You mainly care about the weight trend line, which your Eufy scale already provides reliably
• You’re expecting a dramatic improvement in body-fat accuracy — that expectation isn’t well supported by available evidence
• You don’t need additional ecosystem features like baby/pregnancy modes or deeper app polish
• The price difference isn’t justified by your actual use case

Who Should Buy Withings?

• Best for premium health tracking: Someone who wants a scale that feels like part of a broader, connected health routine
• Best for ecosystem users: Apple Health users, or anyone who wants the option to layer on Withings+ scoring features later
• Best for people who value app experience: Buyers who find a cluttered or basic app frustrating enough to pay more to avoid it
• Best for long-term, whole-household tracking: Families that want pregnancy, baby, and multi-profile support in one device

Who Should Buy Eufy?

• Best for budget-conscious buyers: Anyone who wants solid core functionality without paying a premium
• Best for users who want lots of metrics at a lower price: The P2 Pro’s 16 tracked measurements are hard to match at its typical price point
• Best for beginners: Simple setup and a functional app make this an easy entry point into body-composition tracking
• Best for people who already like the Eufy/Anker ecosystem: If you already use other Eufy or Anker devices, sticking with the brand keeps things simple

Withings vs Eufy: Pros and Cons

Withings Pros:

• Clean, well-organized app
• Broad mode support (Athlete, Pregnancy, Baby, Eyes Closed)
• Native Apple Health support
• Heart rate tracking at each weigh-in
• Supports up to 8 user profiles

Withings Cons:

• Higher price point than Eufy
• Some features locked behind a Withings+ subscription
• Some users report mixed long-term durability and warranty experiences
• No independently published DEXA-comparison data located for this exact model

Eufy Pros:

• Strong metric count (16 measurements) for the price
• No subscription required for core features
• 3D virtual body model for visual progress tracking
• Independent testing showed strong weight-measurement accuracy
• IPX5 water resistance

Eufy Cons:

• Wi-Fi limited to 2.4GHz networks
• App is functional but less polished than Withings’
• Independent testing found body-fat estimates trending higher than DEXA in higher-BMI users
• Fewer household-specific modes (no dedicated pregnancy/baby modes)

Final Verdict — Withings or Eufy?

There’s no universal winner in the Withings vs Eufy smart scale debate — the right choice depends on what you’re optimizing for.

If your priority is app experience, health-ecosystem integration, or household-specific features like pregnancy and baby modes, choose the Withings Body Smart. You’re paying for a more polished, motivating experience layered on top of the same core BIA technology.

If your priority is value — maximum metrics and reliable weight tracking without a subscription nudge — choose the Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro. Independent testing has shown it delivers strong weight accuracy and a wide metric set at a fraction of the Withings price.

Is it worth upgrading from Eufy to Withings? For most people whose main complaint is body-composition accuracy, no — the underlying technology in both scales shares the same fundamental limitations, and there isn’t strong independent evidence that Withings is meaningfully more accurate for body fat or muscle estimates. But if what you actually want is a better app, deeper Apple Health integration, or features your current Eufy model doesn’t have (like Eyes Closed or Pregnancy mode), then yes, the upgrade is likely to deliver what you’re looking for — just go in expecting a better experience, not a more clinically precise one.

LifeCareBalance is a reader-supported site. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Prices and availability are subject to change — always confirm current pricing before purchasing.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Withings better than Eufy? It depends on your priorities. Withings generally offers a more polished app, broader health-ecosystem integration, and more household-specific modes. Eufy generally offers more metrics per dollar and doesn’t require a subscription for core features. Neither is a universal “better” choice.

Is Withings more accurate than Eufy? There’s no strong independent evidence that Withings’ Body Smart is meaningfully more accurate than Eufy’s P2 Pro for body-fat or muscle estimates. Both use similar single-frequency BIA technology, which shares the same fundamental limitations regardless of brand.

Is Eufy body-fat measurement accurate? Independent testing found the Eufy P2 Pro’s weight measurements to be quite precise, but body-fat estimates ran roughly 5–7% higher than DEXA reference testing in higher-BMI users — a limitation common to consumer BIA scales generally, not unique to Eufy.

Is Withings body-fat measurement accurate? Withings’ Body Smart uses the same general BIA approach as most consumer scales, which provides useful trend data rather than clinical precision. We didn’t locate independently published DEXA-comparison data for this specific model, so treat its body-fat readings as directional rather than exact.

Should I upgrade from Eufy to Withings? Only if you want a better app experience, deeper Apple Health integration, or features your Eufy scale lacks, such as Pregnancy or Eyes Closed modes. If your main goal is more accurate body-fat readings, upgrading likely won’t deliver a meaningful improvement.

Which is better for weight loss? Both track weight trends reliably, which is what matters most for weight loss. Withings’ app presents those trends more visually and includes a distraction-free Eyes Closed mode, which some users find helpful for staying motivated without fixating on daily fluctuations.

Which smart scale is better for muscle tracking? Eufy’s P2 Pro reports more granular muscle-related metrics, including skeletal muscle mass and lean body mass. Withings tracks muscle mass as part of its broader body-composition summary. Both are estimates, not clinical measurements.

Does Withings work with Apple Health? Yes, the Withings Body Smart supports Apple Health integration.

Does Eufy work with Apple Health? Yes, the Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro supports Apple Health integration per manufacturer listings.

Do I need a subscription? Not for core features on either scale. Withings gates some extra scoring features (Health Improvement Score, Body Score) behind an optional Withings+ subscription. Eufy’s core feature set doesn’t require a subscription.

Are smart scales accurate for body fat? Consumer smart scales, including both Withings and Eufy models, use bioelectrical impedance analysis, which estimates body fat rather than measuring it directly. They’re useful for tracking trends over time under consistent conditions but shouldn’t be treated as a replacement for clinical body-composition testing like DEXA.

Which smart scale is better for families? Withings has an edge for families thanks to support for up to 8 user profiles plus dedicated Pregnancy and Baby modes. Eufy also supports multiple profiles but doesn’t offer those same household-specific modes.

---

Internal links used:

• <a href=”https://lifecarebalance.com/eufy-smart-scale-p2-pro-review-2026/”>Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro review</a>
• <a href=”https://lifecarebalance.com/withings-body-smart-scale-review-2026/”>Withings Body Smart review</a>

(Massage-gun articles were not linked, since no section of this comparison discussed massage guns or recovery tools in a genuinely relevant context.)

External authoritative sources referenced during research:

• Withings official support documentation (Google Fit/Health Connect transition, Fitbit import tool)
• Manufacturer product listings for Eufy Smart Scale P2 Pro (measurement list, weight capacity, IPX5 rating)
• Independent lab-style testing comparing Eufy P2 Pro readings to DEXA reference standards
• General industry reporting on BIA body-composition scale limitations;https://lifecarebalance.com/